
Back from Book Expo, over the cold, and counting down the panicked days until my job ends and the Columbia Publishing Course begins. And did I mention I have HOMEWORK? I haven't had homework since library school! More on the Columbia course later. On to today's question/rant/musings.
Sometimes I think
Buffy the Vampire Slayer was both the best and worst thing that ever happened to YA literature. Yes, I know it was a TV show and not a book, save for the
Season 8 comics that Dark Horse is printing.
Please don't think that I think Buffy was a bad show, or that it wasn't influential in teen pop culture. I quite enjoyed the seasons I watched (1-4) and do have plans to finish watching to the end of the series via DVD. Eventually. Teens with superpowers were a very hot trend during the run of Buffy. I love Joss Whedon's wit and wisdom and do quote it from time to time. Buffy holds a place in the Great Teen TV Shows Hall of Fame, no doubt, but all of us who work with teens know that their perception of popularity, of hot shows, of important shows, changes every week. Every day, even.
Here's the sad fact we have to face, and if you're a Buffy fan who's my age, meaning you were an older teen or younger adult during the show's run and a fan of the series, one we must accept:
Buffy has been off the air for six years. It ran from 1997-2003. Today's fifteen-year-olds were born in 1994. That means, as far as they're concerned, the show barely existed. Sure, there are teens that are fans of the show, but either I'm oversensitive or they're showing up a lot more in teen literature than they do in real life. (Anyone studied this? I am totally using unscientific anecdata here.) Buffy is no longer the be-all end-all of teen shows, but sometimes I think that the teen literature world is slow to catch on to this fact. I know books are often a year behind pop culture, but this is much more than a year. I'm sure there's at least one book coming down the pipeline somewhere with devoted
Gilmore Girls fans as the characters. (I know I've read one which mentioned a group of girls who were fans of Jensen Ackles, but I don't think the writer did her research because the group always got together on Thursday nights to watch DVDs...during
Supernatural.)
Hey, I didn't say I LIKED acknowledging that fact. But it is a fact. Every generation has the shows that shape it, but every generation's shows can and do come to an end. Buffy has come to an end, and in five years no teens will have memory of its first run. It might not even show in reruns anymore and have to live solely on DVD. And those of us who serve teens and try to provide the latest and greatest in reading and pop culture for them must move on, though Buffy will always have a special place in our hearts.
On the other hand, there was a scene in one of the Twilight books where Bella is listening to a popular rock band. I got annoyed that a band name was never mentioned, but I'm not really sure why.
As for Buffy, it's a great show that I've only recently started watching, but my teens aren't interested in it at all.
Most people don't realize it, but Buffy dramatically changed how television was made, and not just teen dramas, because even though Buffy was about teens, it was never really a teen drama like Dawson's Creek.
It was one of the earliest shows that successfully used serialized story arcs that paved way for great shows like Battlestar Galactica and 24, and less great shows like Heroes, which could have been better. So I agree it was a blessing.
On the other hand, I attribute the popularity of vampirism today to Buffy, because the people creating these new books were watching the show when it was on TV. However, these are usually weak derivatives of a better work, and that's the negative side of it.
It saddens me actually that people love things like Twilight (vampires do not sparkle) but scoff at watching Buffy. My wife is a high school teacher and she actually uses one of the episodes for one of her English classes in order to examine the idea of redemption, because Angel's entire struggle was about redemption. But most of the students think it's weird to watch such an old show and that's the saddest thing of all of this.